Mine has been off my VX for over a year now. Back to the OEM. Weather here simply destroyed it. I am of the opinion that the finish was just cheap since I care for my VX beyond measure and it's garage kept. Mid Atlantic seasons are not known to be generous on vehicles either way.
I have been debating just painting it and putting it back on but if I do not, I will consider selling it. My mind is not made up. Just know though, it looks pretty miserable and chances are, only paint can fix the blemishes.
Gary Noonan
'01 S/C VX / '18 Forester XT