stalling problem...............

[evillecutter]

is it turning over at all? if it just clicks its prob the starter not the fuel pump - if you turn the key on but dont start it and you get pressure on the valve on the fuel line on the side of the intake manifold then you prob dont have a fuel pump problem either and i would say fuel filter

[Y33TREKker]

...oh, lastly, would a mechanic lie about such repair even considering its a big job with a lot of work entailed? It seems he'd try to fix it in an easier fashion. Also considering this is a busy shop. Just wondering. Fwiw, this shop fixed other problems I've had with my vx in cheaper fashion, which makes me believe they honestly know I need said fuel pump replaced.

Let's just say that it wouldn't be the first time in history that an auto repair shop told a customer that their vehicle needed an extensive repair knowing that the problem was actually an easy/quick fix, then charged a lot of labor costs even though hardly any time at all was involved in making the repair.

...lol, you guys will be annoyed by me 2night, but the tech also mentioned that my bad fuel pump contributes to my high idle, which was one problem they lessened recently for me. Is that true?

The problem I personally see with that statement is that if the fuel pump was contributing to a high idle problem, there's really nothing else in the fuel system that could have been adjusted/"lessened" recently except for your throttle linkage. The paranoid side of me is starting to think that they didn't diagnose the root cause of the problem correctly the last time they "lessened" the symptoms you were experiencing, and are now trying cover their previous work by suggesting that a new fuel pump was what was needed all along, because if anything, it seems that an electric fuel pump that's failing would cause the idle to be lower, not higher. At least that diagnosis seems counter-intuitive to me anyway.

[H3_VX]

Let's just say that it wouldn't be the first time in history that an auto repair shop told a customer that their vehicle needed an extensive repair knowing that the problem was actually an easy/quick fix, then charged a lot of labor costs even though hardly any time at all was involved in making the repair.


The problem I personally see with that statement is that if the fuel pump was contributing to a high idle problem, there's really nothing else in the fuel system that could have been adjusted/"lessened" recently except for your throttle linkage. The paranoid side of me is starting to think that they didn't diagnose the root cause of the problem correctly the last time they "lessened" the symptoms you were experiencing, and are now trying cover their previous work by suggesting that a new fuel pump was what was needed all along, because if anything, it seems that an electric fuel pump that's failing would cause the idle to be lower, not higher. At least that diagnosis seems counter-intuitive to me anyway.

I take back my "recently" statement. And I know for a fact they lessened my idle before. I could feel it without a doubt. I was having the hard shifting out of park. They sprayed my MAF and cleaned a few other parts. I just got back from the shop where they let me go in the bay and check out the repair in progress. Also showed me the new pump with new filters. I didn't realize how clean my frame was until today. Some of it is still black, which is odd because I need to replace my rockers due to rust. Its taking them a little bit longer because some of the bolts were not re-usable. He had to make some bolts to fit. I have confidence in these guys, plus not that it matters, but they have extremely high 'AAA' reviews and ratings. My mind might have misinterpreted some of the things he was explaining to me, cause all I could think at the time yesterday was "$700!!!!!!????" LOL! so maybe I heard his idle thing incorrectly. ANYHOOOOO...... :P

[H3_VX]

is it turning over at all? if it just clicks its prob the starter not the fuel pump - if you turn the key on but dont start it and you get pressure on the valve on the fuel line on the side of the intake manifold then you prob dont have a fuel pump problem either and i would say fuel filter

Yes, it would almost turn over. No clicks. Definitely not starter.

[H3_VX]

I would just like to add that I appreciate all of you folks for chiming in and offering your thoughts. I love you all.......................no, not in that way. LOL!

[Y33TREKker]

I take back my "recently" statement. And I know for a fact they lessened my idle before. I could feel it without a doubt. I was having the hard shifting out of park. They sprayed my MAF and cleaned a few other parts...

I didn't doubt what you were saying or the end result you got last time, but regardless of what they may have done to lessen your idle last time, the explanation that high idle was being caused by the fuel pump still makes no sense because the fuel pressure regulator would have prevented excess gas from getting to the engine. Hope the repair takes care of the problem...but seriously....$700 for a fuel pump......[cough]ripoff![cough] Sorry, no way around that one.

[H3_VX]

I didn't doubt what you were saying or the end result you got last time, but regardless of what they may have done to lessen your idle last time, the explanation that high idle was being caused by the fuel pump still makes no sense because the fuel pressure regulator would have prevented excess gas from getting to the engine. Hope the repair takes care of the problem...but seriously....$700 for a fuel pump......[cough]ripoff![cough] Sorry, no way around that one.

$700 includes parts and labor. What would you have expected to pay, just so I know.

[Y33TREKker]

$700 includes parts and labor. What would you have expected to pay, just so I know.

Well, at the risk of this comment coming across as me trying to start a pissing contest (which I'm not), I'd have most likely done the work myself, so my cost wouldn't do you much good for making a comparison since it would just be whatever price I could find on parts and miscellaneous shop items like parts cleaner, etc, etc.

[H3_VX]

Well, at the risk of this comment coming across as me trying to start a pissing contest (which I'm not), I'd have most likely done the work myself, so my cost wouldn't do you much good for making a comparison since it would just be whatever price I could find on parts and miscellaneous shop items like parts cleaner, etc, etc.

LOL, not a pissing contest at all dude. Just talking. Got my baby back today. Runs great now. No issues. Oh, also gave me a AAA discount when I paid the bill even though i'm not a AAA member.