Funny you mention the 4-door thing cause many folks feel teh same way. UNFORTUNATELY, there is a money philosophy behind it that is actually very well thought out. Many sporty cars with 2 doors (think about the VX) made in the past 15 years did not have very good sales. The resale on these vehicles was even worse. Camaro, Mustang, and Firebird had pretty good sales throughout the years, but their major fanbase was second hand owners. First hand owners having sold them something with more rear room access (perhaps this generation was hitting the family stage).
Here is a wild surprise. The Sporty Impala SS that appeared in the late 90's actually sold quite well AND it had four doors. It wasnt meant to be a true sporty car at first (it was rumorured to have been a car that GM was hoping would tackle the Crown Vic for police cruisers, but the police did not care for it) but it ended up being quite popular among middle aged men (families?).
I cant say so much that this 4 door idea has not been well thought out. I think it's a good idea, even if I dont care for four doors. I all, a family man could talk his wife into it since it's easier to throw some munchkins in the back seat. A single, childless cat like me could always compromise with 4 doors, hahaha. I tend to like the Charger a LOT. I have had my eye on it and am actually looking for a second car. Now, don't laugh, but I have had my eye on th Saturn Sky. Zippy, sleek looking, and affordable.
Gary Noonan
'01 S/C VX / '18 Forester XT